← Back to Wars

Sitting Ducks vs Elite Trolls...

CWL R2
30v30
64 - 58
Victory

War Analysis

18 bases not 3-starred

Executive Summary

Sitting Ducks secured a 64-58 victory over Elite Trolls..., driven by a dominant destruction advantage (85.3% to 72.0%) and strong performances from the top and bottom sections. Despite severe coordination issues in the middle map and zero cleanup attempts across 18 un-3-starred bases, heroic high-percentage 2-star hits from lower Town Halls hitting up sealed the win.

Section Performance

top #1-10 9 players
2.2 avg stars
20/27 possible stars
middle #11-20 6 players
1.5 avg stars
9/18 possible stars
bottom #21-30 9 players
2.1 avg stars
19/27 possible stars

Un-3-starred Bases (16 bases attacked but not cleared)

# Defender TH Attacks Best Attackers
1 AsheNBraKe2 18 1 2* SenorGato (TH18): 2*
2 WarPig!! 18 1 1* who am i (TH18): 1*
4 TonyD22 18 1 2* .Duck (TH18): 2*
8 ELITE www.@com 18 1 1* C-Dub (TH18): 1*
10 anthonythegamr2 18 1 2* Loutony (TH18): 2*
12 Vuuduu 18 1 2* Anthony (TH18): 2*
16 Gladiator 18 1 2* Ataraxy Queen (TH18): 2*
18 Anthonythegamer 18 1 2* ManaAlba (TH18): 2*
19 Mike's A Troll1 18 1 2* SlapShot (TH17): 2*
21 Ryan 18 1 2* Shifty (TH17): 2*
23 CHIEF RIO 18 1 1* PRO⚡️EMPEROR (TH18): 1*
26 Ello Asty 18 1 1* Tgeland 2.0 (TH17): 1*
27 CnF 18 1 2* Dark Sparks (TH17): 2*
29 Vuuduu2 18 1 2* Ritz (TH17): 2*
33 krynn 17 1 2* TopShelf (TH17): 2*
39 Богатырь 18 1 2* DeevesMcQueen (TH16): 2*

Missed Attacks (2)

BigDaddyDyl #15 TH18 0/1
Madara #18 TH18 0/1

MVPs (ranked by net stars + clutch bonus)

BOOM!
#7 TH18
3 net stars
3 raw stars — #7: 3* 100%
igo
#22 TH17
3 net stars
3 raw stars — #20: 3* 100%
AlbaMana
#26 TH17
3 net stars
3 raw stars — #24: 3* 100%

Root Cause Analysis

The victory was anchored by the top and bottom sections generating 39 combined stars, alongside lower Town Halls like Ritz, Shifty, and SlapShot securing massive 90%+ 2-stars against TH18s to build an insurmountable destruction lead. However, the clan suffered a near-disastrous collapse in the middle section, where BigDaddyDyl and Madara missed attacks, leaving bases #15 and #17 completely untouched. This lack of coordination cascaded into a complete absence of cleanup attacks clan-wide, leaving 18 bases at 1 or 2 stars, including four TH18s stuck at 1-star.

What-If Scenarios

If Ritz, Shifty, and SlapShot hadn't secured 90%+ 2-star hits against mismatched TH18s, our destruction tiebreaker advantage would have plummeted, putting the war at risk. Conversely, if BigDaddyDyl and Madara had used their missed attacks to clean up the 1-star hits by 'who am i' (#2) or 'C-Dub' (#8), the victory margin would have easily exceeded 10 stars.

Actionable Takeaways

  • ‣ Address the middle section's coordination failures immediately; BigDaddyDyl and Madara must use their attacks to prevent untouched bases like #15 and #17 in future wars.
  • ‣ Implement a mandatory cleanup strategy. Leaving 18 bases without a second attempt, especially 1-star hits by 'who am i', 'C-Dub', and 'PRO⚡️EMPEROR', is a massive strategic vulnerability.
  • ‣ Continue leveraging highly skilled lower Town Halls like Ritz, Shifty, and SlapShot for mismatch hits, as their 90%+ 2-stars on TH18s heavily padded our destruction percentage.
  • ‣ Rely on the consistent opening strength of players like BOOM!, igo, and AlbaMana, who successfully secured 3 net stars on fresh bases to set the early momentum.

Member Performance

★ Atk 1
# Player TH Attacks Stars Targets
1 SenorGato 18 1/1
74% ★★★
#1 TH18
2 who am i 18 1/1
85% ★★★
#2 TH18
3 LilWeezyAna 18 1/1
★★★
#3 TH18
4 .Duck 18 1/1
98% ★★★
#4 TH18
5 The Godfather 18 1/1
★★★
#5 TH18
7 BOOM! 18 1/1
★★★
#7 TH18
8 C-Dub 18 1/1
86% ★★★
#8 TH18
9 Loutony 18 1/1
60% ★★★
#10 TH18
10 Reptar 18 1/1
★★★
#11 TH18
11 Anthony 18 1/1
98% ★★★
#12 TH18
12 Smooth Criminal 18 1/1
★★★
#14 TH18
15 BigDaddyDyl 18 0/1 no attacks
17 Ataraxy Queen 18 1/1
77% ★★★
#16 TH18
18 Madara 18 0/1 no attacks
19 ManaAlba 18 1/1
71% ★★★
#18 TH18
21 SlapShot 17 1/1
92% ★★★
#19 TH18
22 igo 17 1/1
★★★
#20 TH18
23 Shifty 17 1/1
93% ★★★
#21 TH18
24 WARLORD 17 1/1
★★★
#22 TH18
25 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 1/1
82% ★★★
#23 TH18
26 AlbaMana 17 1/1
★★★
#24 TH18
27 Tgeland 2.0 17 1/1
79% ★★★
#26 TH18
28 Dark Sparks 17 1/1
90% ★★★
#27 TH18
30 Ritz 17 1/1
99% ★★★
#29 TH18
31 MJ Belim 17 1/1
★★★
#31 TH18
34 TopShelf 17 1/1
89% ★★★
#33 TH17
35 Shady 17 1/1
★★★
#34 TH18
36 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 1/1
★★★
#37 TH18
40 DeevesMcQueen 16 1/1
87% ★★★
#39 TH18
41 KingSlapShot 17 1/1
★★★
#41 TH17

Attacks

Order Attacker TH Atk# Defender Def# Def TH Stars Destruction
2 SenorGato 18 1st AsheNBraKe2 1 18 ★ ★ ★ 74%
4 BOOM! 18 1st Big T 7 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
14 igo 17 1st MR. E 20 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
15 AlbaMana 17 1st mr.wood 24 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
16 ManaAlba 18 1st Anthonythegamer 18 18 ★ ★ ★ 71%
17 MJ Belim 17 1st Greenmac75 31 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
19 The Godfather 18 1st RedEyedMan 5 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
20 WARLORD 17 1st george0213 22 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
21 Loutony 18 1st anthonythegamr2 10 18 ★ ★ ★ 60%
22 Shady 17 1st gavin 34 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
23 Shifty 17 1st Ryan 21 18 ★ ★ ★ 93%
24 Ataraxy Queen 18 1st Gladiator 16 18 ★ ★ ★ 77%
25 Reptar 18 1st Tommyboy 11 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
26 LilWeezyAna 18 1st Fire and Ice 3 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
30 Smooth Criminal 18 1st CF2 14 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
32 PRO⚡️EMPEROR 18 1st CHIEF RIO 23 18 ★ ★ ★ 82%
35 ⚜Who Dat⚜ 16 1st rma75 37 18 ★ ★ ★ 100%
38 Tgeland 2.0 17 1st Ello Asty 26 18 ★ ★ ★ 79%
39 Anthony 18 1st Vuuduu 12 18 ★ ★ ★ 98%
40 DeevesMcQueen 16 1st Богатырь 39 18 ★ ★ ★ 87%
41 SlapShot 17 1st Mike's A Troll1 19 18 ★ ★ ★ 92%
42 KingSlapShot 17 1st Jake BruiserJK 41 17 ★ ★ ★ 100%
44 who am i 18 1st WarPig!! 2 18 ★ ★ ★ 85%
45 TopShelf 17 1st krynn 33 17 ★ ★ ★ 89%
49 .Duck 18 1st TonyD22 4 18 ★ ★ ★ 98%
50 C-Dub 18 1st ELITE www.@com 8 18 ★ ★ ★ 86%
54 Ritz 17 1st Vuuduu2 29 18 ★ ★ ★ 99%
55 Dark Sparks 17 1st CnF 27 18 ★ ★ ★ 90%